What Jigsaw Can Teach Us About Project Management

- January 26, 2010 - by , in Digital Project Management, with 12 comments -

I want to play a game…

I don’t, but how else can you start a Saw movie themed article?

So there I am watching the latest Saw movie (Saw 6), cringing at the gore levels and twisting plot lines when it hit me, the main character affectionately named “Jigsaw” (or John to his friends) is quite frankly an excellent project manager!

From that point on the movie took on a rather different perspective for me and was transformed into taking notes on how to run multiple projects with pin point precision (and kill people in imaginative ways).

In this article I want to discuss what an insane serial killer can teach all of us about managing projects, or has he calls them, games…

A Saw movie poster with a drawing of Admiral Ackbar on it saying It's a Trap!

A one line synopsis of the Saw movies by a local film critic

Project kick-off meeting

When starting a new game, or project, Jigsaw always conducts an excellent project kick-off meeting. Although always by video or audio (due to certain legal reasons), he always:

  1. Starts with introductions, explaining who he is and who everyone else in the room is
  2. States the purpose of the meeting e.g. “I want to play a game”
  3. Explains why the projects exists (usually because they’ve been a naughty boy or girl)
  4. Communicates the aims and objectives of the project, or in other words, what the goals of the project are and how he intends to achieve the goals
  5. Sets out clear timelines for project completion (usually around two minutes before someone’s head explodes, but at least they are fully aware of the timelines – every cloud…)
  6. Explains all of the above in a language everyone involved can understand.

By following this set of pointers, a project manager should be able to conduct an effective project kick-off meeting that leaves everyone involved with a clear picture of the road ahead.

A movie screenshot of Jigsaw with a menacing stare in front of a countdown clock

Jigsaw always conveys project timelines effectively

However, if you’re reading this John, I would recommend you allow for a little QnA session with people in this kick-off meeting to get other people’s input… just a thought.

Project planning

One of the critical success factors of any project is planning, planning and more planning.

As I’ve mentioned before in my Pragmatic Web Project Planning series, project planning allows the project manager to:

  • Define and manage the project scope
  • Identify and minimise risks to the project
  • Break the allocated project time into manageable phases and tasks
  • Determine realistic milestones and client-side deadlines
  • Track progress and control the project
  • Secure the necessary resource

There is little doubt that Jigsaw was a big project planning fan. His projects had to be so tightly run, without planning he would have definitely been arrested pretty early on, probably in Saw II.

But alas, due to his world-class talent at project planning, scheduling and excellent people skills, giving him the ability to pre-empt most mid-project surprises, he was able to avoid the law and keep his picture on the FBI’s Most Wanted page – hoorah for project planning!

A spoof Gantt chart showing a timeline of a game from Saw

A snippet of a project schedule John kindly sent me

Personally I think Jigsaw would’ve used a Gantt chart as his primary project scheduling tool, as with many projects, more modern project management methodologies such as Agile or Kanban just wouldn’t have been suitable.

Either way, careful inspection of the Saw projects illustrates just how important project planning really is for effective project management, and serial killing.

Project teams are crucial

During the Saw series Jigsaw enlists the help of three people for his project team; some ex-drug addict criminal, his wife and dodgy police officer called Hoffman – we shall refer to them as Team Psycho Nutbags.

Initially in Saw I, Jigsaw manages the project alone with good results, but as he moves onto managing larger projects he realises that he needs support and thus sets about creating his own project team. From this it is clear Jigsaw has learnt a vital lesson, you need a team to get the job done.

Task Delegation and team empowerment

Working as a project manager with a team, Jigsaw demonstrates how delegating key project tasks to team members are a crucial part of managing successful projects.

Many project managers find this a difficult thing to do and usually it’s solely down to trust issues, in that the project manager doesn’t fully trust a team member to complete the task to a good enough standard thus adding risk to the project.

A key lesson Jigsaw has learnt however, is that when you empower team members with a certain level of responsibility they will often exceed your expectations and perform above and beyond.

A movie screenshot of Jigsaw talking to Amanda in a dominating manner

At first John’s team felt overwhelmed by his unique PM style

If as a project manager you have trust issues with team members and feel uneasy delegating key tasks to them, but at the same time clearly have a packed work schedule building death traps, you could start by delegating lower risk tasks to test the water.

These tasks would ideally be challenging but not soul destroying, or you run the risk of the team member thinking you’re just handing out the boring work you can’t be bothered to do.

When delegating any tasks it’s vitally important to always make it clear you are there for them if they need support.

In my experience, and I’m sure Jigsaw’s, what you tend to find is if you delegate the right tasks to the right people and are there to provide support, over time you will trust the team member more and more, they will feel and appreciate that trust and you will be able to hand over more project critical tasks thus freeing up valuable time for yourself to build those torture machines.

Project team development

Not only does Jigsaw demonstrate a supreme skill set when managing projects, but he also understands the advantages in developing his project team’s skills.

A movie screenshot of Jigsaw talking to Detective Hoffman as he is tied to a chair with a shotgun pointed at himself

Although forceful, John’s development techniques are effective

Throughout the Saw series, while personally managing multiple projects, Jigsaw is constantly teaching his project team new skills – but why when he has so much killing to do and so little time?

A good project manager will make it part of their remit to teach their team new skills for a variety of reasons:

  • It increases the skill set of the individuals and thus helps grow the company
  • Team members with new skills can take on more key project tasks
  • Team development increases team morale
  • Willingness to share knowledge rather than protect it improves company culture

In my experience, those who are willing to take the time to develop their teams are the ones that ultimately have the most success simply because people are more willing to work for someone who is clearly not just looking after themselves.

Game over, project completion

As with all projects, it is important to clearly define the markers that define a project as complete.

All too often I hear of projects that have been run really smoothly, encountered few problems until right near the end when the project manager is beginning to talk about completion and the client suddenly pipes up about how they thought they were going to get more features or services before the end… uh oh.

This situation mostly only arises when a project manager has not clearly defined the deliverables, and scope of deliverables, that will constitute the project as complete.

Jigsaw, an experienced veteran project manager never makes this mistake. As previously mentioned, he always clearly states what the project consists of and the victim is never under any other impression, just perhaps under a slow body crushing device with blades.

A movie screenshot of a game player holding his head in despair with a countdown time behind him

What do you mean we only have 15 hours budget left!?

Of course real life project management isn’t as clear cut as Jigsaw’s games (no offence John mate), and often what is stated as the project completion deliverables at the start of a project have changed dramatically by the end, but this is ok, in fact, I would say for larger projects this is completely normal and to be expected.

Many times I’ve been running projects that had several huge shifts mid-lifecycle, for example:

  • New functionality requested that is of higher priority than previously in-scope functionality
  • One or several phases take far longer to implement than initial estimates allowed for
  • Client’s budget or timeline is cut mid-project and an early completion is demanded

In each instance, it was required to re-state the project completion deliverables to the client and the project team so that it was clear to everyone involved where the finishing line was.

Constantly re-establishing the finishing line

Hearing of a project suffering from lack of a clear finishing line at any stage of a project is a subtle way to identify those true practitioners of project management amongst the sea of people just pretending to be project managers… why?

Simply because establishing and re-establishing the finishing line is very easy to do if a project has been run according to project management 101 guidelines.

An image of two Saw dolls, the real one and a bad fake fancy dress one

You can always tell a real project manager from a wannabe

In order to determine project completion deliverables throughout the project you just need to:

  1. List the completion deliverables last communicated
  2. Gather updates on all deliverables progress
  3. Analyse the current budget used and remaining
  4. Estimate the remaining tasks in the project against the remaining budget
  5. Look at the results, are you looking under budget, on budget or over budget
    1. If under budget, smile and tell the client you’re on track
    2. If on budget, smile and tell the client you’re on track
    3. If over budget, smile and try to explain to the client why, negotiate additional budget or provide them with the de-scoped features or features you proposed are moved to a later phase
  6. Once understood, clearly re-state the project completion deliverables and scope in writing and get agreement
  7. Wait a period of time and go back to Step 1

Generally, as with most project information, if you have been honest and consistent with the client from day one, they will understand that the initial estimations were a little off and a slight re-adjustment is needed that means neither side lose out.

It tends to only get ugly when the client has received few progress reports, been told everything is great for the whole project and then suddenly has a project manager pushing back on everything spouting “out of scope” and “over budget” phrases – phrases that must feel exactly the same as if the agency was cutting a jigsaw shape from their flesh!

Although don’t forget to always get your agency’s credentials in the website footer, always leave your mark – another great tip from John.

Despite all the bad feeling John’s players must have towards him and his games, if you could stitch all their limbs back together and re-animate them, I doubt a single one of them could whinge that they didn’t know where the finishing line was in their game.

Formal project completion documentation

Assuming you’re an awesome project manager like John Kramer, you will rarely come up against this problem of hazy project completion, and as well as the finishing line always being clear to everyone involved, you’ll also make sure you formally close the project with documentation and a client signature – ahhh, there is little sweeter than when you get the written confirmation that the project is complete and any extra work will require further funding.

Of course you could just try ringing or mailing the client and saying “Game Over”, but I just can’t see this going down to well, unless of course you have fostered a Saw movie theme with your client throughout the project, in which case you’re amazingly cool and so is the client and I want to be both of your friends forever and ever and ever.

Project management 3D glasses

Although this article hasn’t professed any remarkable project management revelations, hopefully you can see past the slightly odd dark association, don your 3D glasses, look past the initial visual layer and appreciate the links and inspiration you can make and take between project management, and general digital work, that you see in everyday life rather than just relying on project management books and blogs.

These everyday associations are brilliantly pointed out in articles and presentations like…

Phil Bennet’s Project Management is like Star Wars article, where he maps things like Han Solo being frozen in Carbonite and The Force to project management.

Adaptive Path’s SWSX 2008 presentation entitle 10 Tips for Managing Creative Environments where Bryan Mason and Sarah Nelson talk about how professional kitchens and orchestras are run as a tight knit team in relation to running a digital team.

Andy Budd’s presentation on UX where he presents analogies of website user experience based on when you first walk into a hotel lobby.

So the next time you watch a movie, order a coffee or arrive at a hotel, be a super nerd and try to recognise how the processes you see could help you in your current role.

ARTICLE OVER!

Related reading:

1 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  • Pingback: Czego Jigsaw mógłby Ciebie nauczyć o project management'cie? on January 26, 2010

12

- Comments -

  • Loved this article! “re-establishing the finishing line” is something I definately need to get better at.

  • Czego Jigsaw mógłby Ciebie nauczyć o project management'cie?

    […] http://www.thesambarnes.com Follow us on Twitter 23 śledzących RSS Feed 186 czytelników Czego Jigsaw mógłby Ciebie nauczyć o project management'cie? 1 głosuj! Jigsaw (tak, tak – ten z Piły) jest osobą dość kontrowersyjną i rzadko […]

  • Great! One of the best article about project management, which I recently read.

  • Now I know how to hold a damn good kick-off meeting. Interesting and fun to read though I’d never seen SAW movies. Thanks!

  • Rob Smith

    Sam, great article – thoroughly enjoyed it. Bit that made me laugh the most:

    # If under budget, smile and tell the client you’re on track
    # If on budget, smile and tell the client you’re on track

    So true!

    Question though – without the threat of imminent death, what are some effective techniques to keep a project tight to timescales and budget?

  • This is one of the most engrossing, fun, and well written articles on project management for beginners I’ve ever read.

    Love the pictures differentiating a real Project Manager from a wannabe.

  • heffe

    Sam, very nice article both very entertaining and very practical!

  • @Stanton, it’s something I’ve got better at in the last year or so and is a massive helper when it comes to closing a project on budget.

    @Rob, ha, isn’t it just too true :) As for keeping projects to a tight deadline and budget, wow, now there’s the ultimate project management question huh. In short, I’d say the key tips are to break down the project into tasks against the budget you have, identify tasks that you cant fit in and tell the client, de-scope features to fit the hours you can allocate to it, create a realistic schedule that you always revise and just keep real close to the project at all phases, pushing back the client whenever you have too.

    There’s a whole blog post idea there huh ;) What are your top tips for achieving this?

    @timothy, Glad you liked the kick off meeting section :)

    @Karol @PMHut @heffe, thanks so much for your comments. I really enjoyed writing this post too.

  • Jamin

    great article, providing me with some great advice and assistance for someone new starting out in the PM world. so any other help/advice would be great.

    love the blog though thanks!

  • @Jamin, glad you liked this one, I had fun writing it!

  • Anne

    This is a great article! I have already shared it with friends.

  • @Anne, thanks! Out of curiosity, how did you find this article? :)

Leave

- Your Comment -